Was It Child Abuse, or Was It an Accident?

Brenda and Josh say their baby was taken from them after she accidentally fell off Josh's lap, and he is now in prison.

Writing:
  • Oprah Winfrey
  • Phil McGraw

Stars:
Release Date: 2002-09-16
Seasons: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21
TMDb: 4.9/10
  • Country: US
  • Language: English
  • Runtime: 42

Other episodes for this season

Vanished on Vacation: Beautiful Blonde Goes Missing in Aruba
Episode 1 - Vanished on Vacation: Bea...
Exclusive: The Father Acquitted of Murdering the Drunk Driver Who Killed His Sons
Episode 2 - Exclusive: The Father Acq...
Sons of Guns Reality Show Scandal: The Daughter Speaks Out
Episode 3 - Sons of Guns Reality Show...
Get Out of My House: The Ultimate Mother-Nanny Feud
Episode 4 - Get Out of My House: The...
Exclusive: The Mother Who Attempted to Kill Herself and Her Autistic Daughter
Episode 5 - Exclusive: The Mother Who...
Exclusive: Kelli Stapleton: A Mother's Worst Nightmare
Episode 6 - Exclusive: Kelli Stapleto...
Is Mom Leading a Secret Life, or Are These Daughters Caught Up in Drama?
Episode 7 - Is Mom Leading a Secret L...
NFL Domestic Violence: There Are No Sidelines, Only Sides
Episode 8 - NFL Domestic Violence: Th...
My Mom Ruined My Life by Keeping Me from My Dad
Episode 9 - My Mom Ruined My Life by...
I Spanked My Wife With a Wooden Spoon, and She Needs to Repent
Episode 10 - I Spanked My Wife With a...
My Husband Spanked Me With a Wooden Spoon, and He Wants Me to Apologize?!
Episode 11 - My Husband Spanked Me Wit...
E.R. Visits, Nearly 100 Calls to Police: Should They Redo Their I Dos?
Episode 12 - E.R. Visits, Nearly 100 C...
Two Mothers Facing the Unthinkable
Episode 13 - Two Mothers Facing the Un...
He's Nearly 30 and Engaged to My Teen With Braces
Episode 14 - He's Nearly 30 and Engage...
My Ex Won't Stop Videotaping and Posting Our Out of Control Son's Tantrums
Episode 15 - My Ex Won't Stop Videotap...
The War of the Larosa's
Episode 16 - The War of the Larosa's
Love Scams: My Mother Sent Her Catfish 300k Plus 3 Cars
Episode 17 - Love Scams: My Mother Sen...
Family on Fire: Caught on Tape
Episode 18 - Family on Fire: Caught on...
I'm Afraid of My Mother: Does She Really Have Multiple Personalities
Episode 19 - I'm Afraid of My Mother:...
Our Dad Left Our Dying Mother for a Woman Who Claims to Be a Kennedy Heir
Episode 20 - Our Dad Left Our Dying Mo...
A Family's Battle With a Violent, Homicidal, Schizophrenic Son
Episode 21 - A Family's Battle With a...
An Online Hate Group is Stalking Us and Ruining Our Lives
Episode 22 - An Online Hate Group is S...
My Honor Roll Teen is Pregnant by Her 30-Year-Old Bad Boy
Episode 23 - My Honor Roll Teen is Pre...
My Scheming, Lying, Swindling Sister
Episode 24 - My Scheming, Lying, Swind...
Give My Daughter Back or Get Out of My Life!
Episode 25 - Give My Daughter Back or...
10 Psychiatrists, 7 Psych Wards and 7 Arrests: My Son is Like a Wild Animal!
Episode 26 - 10 Psychiatrists, 7 Psych...
My Husband Kidnapped My Kids 45 Years Ago -- Help Me Find Them!
Episode 27 - My Husband Kidnapped My K...
A Father Accused: The Search for the Truth
Episode 28 - A Father Accused: The Sea...
Should They Kick Him Out?
Episode 29 - Should They Kick Him Out?
Why is My Prince Charming Hurting Me?
Episode 30 - Why is My Prince Charming...
Who's Stalking Who?: Two Women Obsessed
Episode 31 - Who's Stalking Who?: Two...
Footsteps in the Snow: The Cold Case Murder of Maria Ridulph
Episode 32 - Footsteps in the Snow: Th...
A Real-Life “Catch Me if You Can”: Is This the World's Greatest Teen Con Artist?
Episode 33 - A Real-Life “Catch Me if...
Bob and Dorothy Return: “Should I Divorce My Wife for Harassing Me?”
Episode 34 - Bob and Dorothy Return: “...
Handsome and Homeless: A Down-and-Out Romeo
Episode 35 - Handsome and Homeless: A...
Bright, Beautiful and Blowing It: “Help My Teen Before It's Too Late!”
Episode 36 - Bright, Beautiful and Blo...
Minny and Lon Return: “What Can We Do to Get Our Children Out of Foster Care?”
Episode 37 - Minny and Lon Return: “Wh...
Abused Wife Refuses to Leave Her Pro Fighter Husband
Episode 38 - Abused Wife Refuses to Le...
Death on 5th Avenue: Millionaire Mom Accused of Murdering Son Speaks from Rikers Island
Episode 39 - Death on 5th Avenue: Mill...
The Mystery of Michelle O'Connell: A Family Divided
Episode 40 - The Mystery of Michelle O...
Three Daughters, Three Addicts, One Family Being Torn Apart
Episode 41 - Three Daughters, Three Ad...
Lethal Love: “We Believe Our Son's Girlfriend Killed Him”
Episode 42 - Lethal Love: “We Believe...
The Secret World of Sugar Babies & Kendra Wilkinson on Top
Episode 43 - The Secret World of Sugar...
Shocking Accusations: A Husband Poisoned? A Hit and Run?
Episode 44 - Shocking Accusations: A H...
Hypochondriac, High Drama or Really Sick? “My Sister's Illnesses are Destroying Our Family”
Episode 45 - Hypochondriac, High Drama...
Hypochondriac, High Drama or Really Sick? Saving Shemida
Episode 46 - Hypochondriac, High Drama...
Blacklisted by Mom: “Can We Speak to Our Dad Before He Dies?”
Episode 47 - Blacklisted by Mom: “Can...
Survivor Todd's Shocking Relapse: The Life or Death Intervention
Episode 48 - Survivor Todd's Shocking...
Will Survivor Todd Take Dr. Phil’s Help? Plus, What Happened to “Homeless Joe”?
Episode 49 - Will Survivor Todd Take D...
The “Here Comes Honey Boo Boo” Scandal: Mama June Speaks Out
Episode 50 - The “Here Comes Honey Boo...
Exclusive: The Boy under the Stairs? What Did His Stepmom Know? Plus, Uncle Poodle Responds to Mama June
Episode 51 - Exclusive: The Boy under...
A Dentist's Dilemma: “My Ex-Wife and Ex-Girlfriend Are Plotting against Me!”
Episode 52 - A Dentist's Dilemma: “My...
Molested for over 10 Years: “Why Won't My Grandma Believe Me?”
Episode 53 - Molested for over 10 Year...
Grandma Returns: Will She Finally Apologize for Her Molester Husband?
Episode 54 - Grandma Returns: Will She...
“My Drunken Daughter Will Die if She Doesn't Stop Drinking Hand Sanitizer”
Episode 55 - “My Drunken Daughter Will...
“My Father Offered Me as a 'Maiden' Sacrifice to an Alleged Cult Leader”
Episode 56 - “My Father Offered Me as...
“My Wife or My Girlfriend? Dr. Phil, You Decide”
Episode 57 - “My Wife or My Girlfriend...
Cyberbullied After My Son's Death
Episode 58 - Cyberbullied After My Son...
A Daughter on the Brink: Did Mom Push Her Over the Edge?
Episode 59 - A Daughter on the Brink:...
“My Fight With Food Is Ruining My Life”
Episode 60 - “My Fight With Food Is Ru...
Gold Digger or Girl in Danger?
Episode 61 - Gold Digger or Girl in Da...
“I Thought My Daughter Was Abducted”: Why Does This Pretty 16-Year-Old Keep Going Missing?
Episode 62 - “I Thought My Daughter Wa...
“My Husband Used to Abuse Me, So Now I'm Abusing Him”
Episode 63 - “My Husband Used to Abuse...
“My Bulimic Daughter Thinks Calories are Contagious”
Episode 64 - “My Bulimic Daughter Thin...
A Woman's Memories of Murder: Was There a Crime or Another Traumatic Event?
Episode 65 - A Woman's Memories of Mur...
The Cougar Controversy: Older Women Dating Younger Men
Episode 66 - The Cougar Controversy: O...
The “Honey Boo Boo” Scandal: Chickadee and Grandma Speak Out
Episode 67 - The “Honey Boo Boo” Scand...
Black and Blue: Race Relations in America
Episode 68 - Black and Blue: Race Rela...
Young, in Love and in over Their Heads
Episode 69 - Young, in Love and in ove...
Is Dad a Bad Santa or Should His Son Be Put on the Naughty List?
Episode 70 - Is Dad a Bad Santa or Sho...
The Night Four Girls Went into the Woods and Only Three Came Out Alive
Episode 71 - The Night Four Girls Went...
“I'm Divorcing the Real-Life Mommy Dearest”
Episode 72 - “I'm Divorcing the Real-L...
Inside the Bill Cosby Sex Scandal
Episode 73 - Inside the Bill Cosby Sex...
Mom vs. Dad: Who is Responsible for Their Daughter's Big Relapse?
Episode 74 - Mom vs. Dad: Who is Respo...
Get Off My Back About My Body
Episode 75 - Get Off My Back About My...
“My Mother is a Menace! She is Controlling My Daughter with Her Money and Turning Her against Me!”
Episode 76 - “My Mother is a Menace! S...
“Dr. Phil, Save My Family”
Episode 77 - “Dr. Phil, Save My Family...
300 Women and Counting: “My Brother is Addicted to Everything, and It's All My Mom's Fault”
Episode 78 - 300 Women and Counting: “...
Wild Behavior Caught on Camera
Episode 79 - Wild Behavior Caught on C...
Pretty, Young and Violent
Episode 80 - Pretty, Young and Violent
Why is My Mom Faking Cancer?
Episode 81 - Why is My Mom Faking Canc...
My Mother Refuses to Cut the Cord with My Mama’s Boy Brother
Episode 82 - My Mother Refuses to Cut...
Yes, I Abandoned My Children, but I’m Not a Bad Mom
Episode 83 - Yes, I Abandoned My Child...
15 and a Teenage Terror
Episode 84 - 15 and a Teenage Terror
“My Parents Won't Accept My Controlling Pastor Husband”
Episode 85 - “My Parents Won't Accept...
“Who Am I Married to: My Mother or My Man?”
Episode 86 - “Who Am I Married to: My...
“My Family Doesn’t Know I’m a College-Aged Sugar Baby”
Episode 87 - “My Family Doesn’t Know I...
What Happened to Tempest?: Standing Up to Mean Girls
Episode 88 - What Happened to Tempest?...
Parental Alienation or Runaway Sisters?: “Help Me Find My Teen Daughters”
Episode 89 - Parental Alienation or Ru...
“I'm Scared of My Sister's Boyfriend”: Is He a Danger to Her Children?
Episode 90 - “I'm Scared of My Sister'...
Shocking Viral Video: Teen Says, “If Your Boyfriend Hits You, It's a Sign of Love”
Episode 91 - Shocking Viral Video: Tee...
From Top TV Newscaster to Drunken Mom
Episode 92 - From Top TV Newscaster to...
Gorgeous, Violent, Raging and a Very Unsweet 16
Episode 93 - Gorgeous, Violent, Raging...
A Family Divided over an Unsolved Murder
Episode 94 - A Family Divided over an...
“Is My Wife Real or a Nigerian Love Scam?”
Episode 95 - “Is My Wife Real or a Nig...
“Don't Give My Daughter Money: She is Lying about Dying from Cancer”
Episode 96 - “Don't Give My Daughter M...
“My 21-Year-Old Daughter is Obsessed with Her Controlling, Jealous, Heroin-Addicted Boyfriend”
Episode 97 - “My 21-Year-Old Daughter...
Our Son Was Making Millions, but is Now Living in Our Garage with His Girlfriend
Episode 98 - Our Son Was Making Millio...
Exclusive: The Vanderbilt Football Player’s Interview from behind Bars
Episode 99 - Exclusive: The Vanderbilt...
Pretty Little Mean Girls
Episode 100 - Pretty Little Mean Girls
“Our Sister Lived in the Bushes and Tried to Hire Someone to Kill Her”
Episode 101 - “Our Sister Lived in the...
Parenting While Intoxicated
Episode 102 - Parenting While Intoxicat...
Riches to Rags: “My Son's Fiancée is Ruining His Life”
Episode 103 - Riches to Rags: “My Son's...
The Student and the Professor: Is One Stalking the Other?
Episode 104 - The Student and the Profe...
“My 4-Year-Old Daughter Crushes Her Candy Like Her Dad Crushes His Pain Pills”
Episode 105 - “My 4-Year-Old Daughter C...
The Ultimate Betrayal: A Toxic Family Love Triangle
Episode 106 - The Ultimate Betrayal: A...
“My Ex is Evil; I Want to See My Kids”
Episode 107 - “My Ex is Evil; I Want to...
“My Sister Published a Book of Lies about Our Family”
Episode 108 - “My Sister Published a Bo...
Time is Running Out for Prison-Bound Dad: Did His Wife Blackmail Him into Embezzling $300,000?
Episode 109 - Time is Running Out for P...
“I Believe My Cousin is Squandering Her Inheritance on a Love Scam”
Episode 110 - “I Believe My Cousin is S...
A Modern Day Bonnie and Clyde, or Confused Teens in Love?
Episode 111 - A Modern Day Bonnie and C...
“I Am the Outcast of My Family, and They Threw Me Away Like Trash!”
Episode 112 - “I Am the Outcast of My F...
“My Husband's Big Lottery Win is Ruining Our Marriage”
Episode 113 - “My Husband's Big Lottery...
“My Wife Chose Her Boyfriend over Her Children”
Episode 114 - “My Wife Chose Her Boyfri...
Young, Jealous Love
Episode 115 - Young, Jealous Love
Adoption Nightmare: “I Want My Baby Back”
Episode 116 - Adoption Nightmare: “I Wa...
“My Daughter Hasn't Spoken to Me in 7 Years: What's Wrong with Her?”
Episode 117 - “My Daughter Hasn't Spoke...
In Sickness and in Health: “Should I Get a Divorce from My OCD Wife?”
Episode 118 - In Sickness and in Health...
“Our 7-Year-Old Son Threatens to Kill Us!”
Episode 119 - “Our 7-Year-Old Son Threa...
Exclusive: Bobbi Kristina’s Boyfriend, Distraught and Out of Control: The Nick Gordon Intervention
Episode 120 - Exclusive: Bobbi Kristina...
Inside the Mind of the Man Who Shot the “American Sniper”: A Dr. Phil Exclusive
Episode 121 - Inside the Mind of the Ma...
Nine Seconds that Outraged a Nation/“My Racist Father Needs to Accept the Minorities in My Family”
Episode 122 - Nine Seconds that Outrage...
Young, Beautiful and Missing/“Homeless Joe” Returns
Episode 123 - Young, Beautiful and Miss...
Lifetime Grudge: Can Mother and Daughter Finally Bury the Hatchet?
Episode 124 - Lifetime Grudge: Can Moth...
1,000 Lies and Counting: A Husband Who Can't Tell the Truth
Episode 125 - 1,000 Lies and Counting:...
Help! My Daughter is Addicted to Dangerous Men
Episode 126 - Help! My Daughter is Addi...
“Falsely Accused of Murder and Now My Life is Spiraling out of Control”
Episode 127 - “Falsely Accused of Murde...
Flirty Emails and Suspicious Photos: “Is My Husband a Cheater or Just a Charmer?”
Episode 128 - Flirty Emails and Suspici...
Decades of Hatred, Accusations and Altercations: A Fight for Custody That's Tearing a Mother and Daughter Apart
Episode 129 - Decades of Hatred, Accusa...
“Is Our Son a Kleptomaniac?”
Episode 130 - “Is Our Son a Kleptomania...
“I've Divorced My Ex Twice, but I'm Still in Love”
Episode 131 - “I've Divorced My Ex Twic...
“My Mother Gambled $2.5 Million Away and Blames Me for Being Broke”
Episode 132 - “My Mother Gambled $2.5 M...
A Beautiful Teen Forced to Live a Horrible Nightmare: “I Was Held Captive by an Online 'Friend'”
Episode 133 - A Beautiful Teen Forced t...
“My Husband Makes Me Think I'm Crazy, Then Videotapes Me:” Accusations of Abuse Caught on Camera
Episode 134 - “My Husband Makes Me Thin...
“Keep My Ex-Daughter-in-Law Away From My Family”
Episode 135 - “Keep My Ex-Daughter-in-L...
Accusations of Beatings, Starvation and Being Locked in a Room: Who’s Telling the Truth?
Episode 136 - Accusations of Beatings,...
A Family Fighting over a Double-Murder/Psychic Medium John Edward Returns!
Episode 137 - A Family Fighting over a...
An Ex Accused of Stalking, Obsession and Abuse: Who's Telling the Truth?
Episode 138 - An Ex Accused of Stalking...
“I Believe My Parents are Enabling My Freeloading, Drug-Using, Model Brother & It Needs to Stop Today!”
Episode 139 - “I Believe My Parents are...
My Model Brother Wants My Parents to Keep His Secret — Why He Stormed Off the Stage
Episode 140 - My Model Brother Wants My...
Cleveland Abduction: The Michelle Knight Movie and the Brutal Scenes She Couldn't Face
Episode 141 - Cleveland Abduction: The...
A Deadly Love Affair: The Widow, The Lover and The Spouse Behind Bars
Episode 142 - A Deadly Love Affair: The...
Exclusive: The Co-Eds and the Catfish
Episode 143 - Exclusive: The Co-Eds and...
Was It Child Abuse, or Was It an Accident?
Episode 144 - Was It Child Abuse, or Was It an Accident?
Real Housewife’s Exclusive: Kim Richards Tells All about Drunken Arrest
Episode 145 - Real Housewife’s Exclusiv...
The College Professor and His Many Women
Episode 146 - The College Professor and...
“My Stepmother Blew All of My Father's Money on a Scam Artist!”
Episode 147 - “My Stepmother Blew All o...
Uncovering a Catfish: The Battle Between Kaye & Kathy Continues
Episode 148 - Uncovering a Catfish: The...
Family's Fight over Father's Inheritance
Episode 149 - Family's Fight over Fathe...
A Family Divided: Why is Outspoken Dad Carl Boycotting His Daughter's Wedding?
Episode 150 - A Family Divided: Why is...
“My Cyberbullied Daughter Killed Herself, Now I'm Being Harassed Online by a Stranger”
Episode 151 - “My Cyberbullied Daughter...
Convicted Grandpa Still Claims He is Innocent of Molestation
Episode 152 - Convicted Grandpa Still C...
Convicted Grandpa Accused of Molestation Finally Speaks Out
Episode 153 - Convicted Grandpa Accused...
“I'm Not Unstable; Give Me My Children Back”
Episode 154 - “I'm Not Unstable; Give M...
A Mother Accused of Being Unfit and Unstable: Did Jennifer Pass the Drug Test?
Episode 155 - A Mother Accused of Being...
Behind the Buggies and Bonnets: Amish Mafia Star Under Attack
Episode 156 - Behind the Buggies and Bo...
Young and Beautiful: But Their Love is Ugly
Episode 157 - Young and Beautiful: But...
Mother of the Year Turned Stalker: Terrorizes Couple for Outbidding Her on Dream Home
Episode 158 - Mother of the Year Turned...
“My Friends Shaved Their Heads and Got Tattoos Because I Had Cancer, but It Was All a Lie”
Episode 159 - “My Friends Shaved Their...
Teacher Scandal Confession: She Had Sex with Her 15-Year-Old Student
Episode 160 - Teacher Scandal Confessio...
A Wife Goes Missing: Is Her Husband to Blame?
Episode 161 - A Wife Goes Missing: Is H...
She Left Her Babies Alone in a Car: Criminal or Mom Misunderstood?
Episode 162 - She Left Her Babies Alone...
Mentally Ill or Monster? Teen Convicted of Murdering Mom with a Sledgehammer Speaks
Episode 163 - Mentally Ill or Monster?...
“I Hear Voices in My Head, but I'm Not Mentally Ill! Why Won't My Family Believe Me”
Episode 164 - “I Hear Voices in My Head...
Hundreds of Photos in a Box: Snapshots by an Admirer Who She Calls Her Stalker
Episode 165 - Hundreds of Photos in a B...
Won’t Work, Won’t Go to School: “My Son Just Wants to Game All Day”
Episode 166 - Won’t Work, Won’t Go to S...
“I Married My Sister's Boyfriend, And It's Time She Moves On”
Episode 167 - “I Married My Sister's Bo...
A Teen Admits to Killing His 11-Year-Old Brother: Who is Really to Blame?
Episode 168 - A Teen Admits to Killing...
Stun Gun, Plastic Ties and Metal Handcuffs: “My Husband is Accused of Serial Rape”
Episode 169 - Stun Gun, Plastic Ties an...
Dead Man Walking: Susan Sarandon Tries to Save a Man from Death Row
Episode 170 - Dead Man Walking: Susan S...
Is This Father's Extreme Parenting to Blame for His Daughters' Disorders?
Episode 171 - Is This Father's Extreme...
Lies, Lust and a Missing Million? My Ex Needs to Confess
Episode 172 - Lies, Lust and a Missing...
Inside the Bill Cosby Sex Scandal: New Accusers with New Revelations
Episode 173 - Inside the Bill Cosby Sex...
“My Wife Spends Thousands on Kratom Tea” ... “My Husband Tricked Me into Signing Our House over to Him!”
Episode 174 - “My Wife Spends Thousands...